An Open Goal for Investors

Richard Gardiner, EU Public Policy Lead at the World Benchmarking Alliance, says CSDDD offers a rare opportunity to improve corporate human rights risk accountability.

The EU’s recently approved Corporate Sustainability Due Diligence Directive (CSDDD) has the potential to systematically change the way corporations approach their human rights risks, both within their operations and supply chains. It will do this by setting a legal baseline outlining exactly how the largest multinationals operating in the EU are expected to address these risks across their global supply chains.

The passing of this law has been hailed as a significant victory in the sustainability community. Investors in particular should be paying close attention to these developments, as CSDDD presents both challenges and opportunities that can significantly impact their portfolios.

Why CSDDD matters to investors

One of the most compelling reasons for investors to care about and invest time in understanding CSDDD is the enhanced leverage it provides. The law offers a legal and political framework to mandates companies to proactively tackle their human rights risks, which investors can utilise to push for greater corporate accountability. By directly referencing these legal obligations, investors can exert pressure on companies to engage more deeply with human rights issues within their value chains. Unlike the existing voluntary global standards, the leverage provided by CSDDD is not just theoretical. It has practical implications for improving corporate behaviour and, by extension, protecting the long-term value of investments.

Investors are not merely passive observers of corporate performance but have a proactive role to play. By incorporating CSDDD in their responsible investment practices, investors can ensure that the leverage provided is not just a by-product of the law but becomes a mainstream expectation across the investment community. This mainstreaming is vital for preventing and addressing both current and potential negative impacts on people, managing financial risks, and meeting the evolving expectations of beneficiaries, civil society, regulators and clients.

Current landscape and investor opportunities

This pressure point is more important now than ever. Data from the World Benchmarking Alliance’s Corporate Human Rights Benchmark (CHRB) underscores the urgency of CSDDD. Although 66% of benchmarked companies in high-risk sectors have demonstrated improvement on key human rights indicators, a staggering 40% still disclose no or insufficient evidence of a human rights due diligence process. This indicates a significant gap between current practices and the standards that the CSDDD aims to enforce. Investors, armed with the

Take Five: Balance of Power

A selection of the major stories impacting ESG investors, in five easy pieces. 

A stark message in Bonn underlined the tensions between electoral cycles and long-term sustainability.  

Climate “collusion” – Republican politicians faced off against US institutional investors on Capitol Hill this week, in the latest round of the war on ‘woke’ capitalism. Having published a report claiming “bullying” of members by the investor-led Climate Action 100+ (CA100+) coalition, the House Judiciary Subcommittee on the Administrative State, Regulatory Reform, and Anti-trust heard from investor network Ceres, shareholder advocacy group As You Sow and CalPERS – the US’s largest public pension fund. Ceres CEO Mindy Lubber opened her testimony asserting: “Climate change, water scarcity and pollution, and nature loss … pose material financial risks to investment portfolios, business operations and supply chains, thus to the long-term stability of our markets and the economy.” As a member of its global steering committee, Lubber was also representing CA100+, which insisted its members “act as independent fiduciaries, responsible for their individual investment and voting decisions”. The stated purpose of the hearings was to decide whether current laws are sufficient to “deter anti-competitive collusion” to promote ESG-related goals in the investment industry. A legal memo recently secured by the US Sustainable Investment Forum found that firms and investors acting in concert on climate risks “are not violating fiduciary duty and are at negligible risk for anti-trust claims”. Even so, the hearings could be contributing to rising outflows from sustainable investment vehicles, with investor behaviour in the US diverging from elsewhere. Among the evidence cited for reduced appetite was the closure of several funds by BlackRock, some sustainability focused, others – less so, including one targeting opportunities arising from remote working. But it’s far from clear whether the world’s largest asset manager has given up on sustainable investing, given its launch this week of a series of climate transition-focused exchange-traded funds.

Slightly right – The rightward shift of the European Parliament following last week’s elections has prompted divergent views on its implications for the Green Deal that MEPs spent much of the past five years constructing. Centre- and far-right parties swelled their presence largely at the expense of the Greens and the moderate liberal Renew grouping – albeit with voting outcomes contrasting vastly across member states. There is scope for this new cohort to weaken some measures that are still being finalised, such as the

A Solvable Problem

The world is off track to end deforestation, but accelerating financial sector and policy action could help change course. The fight to end deforestation is at a critical juncture ahead of a UN-backed recommendation for reaching net zero commodity-driven deforestation by 2025, as part of efforts to keep global warming…

Subscribe

Subscribe to ESG Investor to gain access to the leading platform for news, analysis, and interviews across sustainable investing. Select subscribe below to view our subscription packages or you can email us at subscriptions@esginvestor.net to discuss your options.

Subscribe

Request a Trial

Get in touch today to discuss a trial giving you unrestricted and unlimited access to ESG Investor for you and/or your team(s) for a limited period. Email us at subscriptions@esginvestor.net

Related Items:, , , , , , , , , , , , Recommended for you